RPA and beyond

Hartree-Fock and all it's extensions (up to HF-Bogoliubov in the most general quasiparticle formalism) are static, independent particle models. By a proper definition of (quasi)particles we can explain the basic properties of the ground states of many nuclei, and also some of their excited states.
But there are many other excited states that cannot be reproduced by the above. These missing excitations will be explained by collective, many-body (coherent) correlations within the nucleus:

  1. Their EM transition probabilities are one or two orders of magnitude larger than the single-particle transitions.
  2. They show up in the spectra of different nuclei with great regularity. A good example is the giant dipole resonance.

This is treated in the context of the residual interaction, i.e., the difference between the full, many-body potential and the HF mean field. It will give an explanation of high-lying (resonances) and low lying (bound states) collective vibrations.
These collective states arise mostly from the long-range part of the nuclear force, i.e., the particle-hole pairing force.

Note:

The Tamm-Dancoff method is a first approach to tackling the interaction between ph-pairs. It is superseded by RPA in several ways, mainly in that TD does not take into account these correlations for the ground state, which remains unmodified.

RPA equations from linear response theory

This section is restricted to assuming we are working with a plain HF solution (no quasiparticle spice), but it can be adapted. We can find the RPA (Random Phase Approximation) equations by investigating the influence of a weak external time-dependent field:

F(t)=Feiωt+Feiωt.

With F(t)=klfkl(t)akal a one-body operator.
The nuclear density will oscillate with this external field, and we obtain resonances whenever ω is close to an excitation energy.

The WF of the nuclear system is no longer stationary, but a wavepacket. It's single body density is:

ρkl(t)=Φ(t)|akal|Φ(t)

Approximations used from now on:

  1. We assume ρ(t) corresponds to a Slater determinant at all time. So it obeys this e.o.m.:

    iρ˙=[h[ρ]+f(t),ρ]

    where h is the single-particle HF field.

  2. The external field is weak, so it introduces only small oscillations around the stationary density ρ(0). We can then write

    ρ(t)=ρ(0)+δρ(t)

    with δρ=ρ(1)eiωt+ρ(1)eiωt. Here ρ(1) is the density of the excited states.

We work in the HF basis, where ρ(0) is diagonal, meaning:

ρkl(0)=δklρk(0)={0for particles1for holes

In Hartree-Fock we saw that the condition ρ2=ρ implies that the only non-vanishing elements of ρ(1) are hp and ph elements.
We can now expand the e.o.m. to first order in f:

iδρ˙=[h0,δρ]+[δhδρδρ,ρ(0)]+[f,ρ(0)]

(we have used some commutator algebra here). Using the properties of Slater determinant densities we see that the pp and hh components of the above equation vanish. We

QRPA

This is the most complete way of treating harmonic perturbations, and can be used as a plug-in to HFB